The Hills Are Alive



Heading to the hospital on a train, in Vienna, Austria, Maria Augusta Kutschera was born on January 26, 1905.  Maria married Georg Von Trapp on November 26, 1927 in Austria before the Nazi takeover of Austria.  It was this Maria, that Rogers and Hammerstein fashioned their legendary Maria in The Sound of Music.  There are similarities and differences between the “grand story” of Maria in The Sound of Music,  and Maria Augusta Kutschera Von Trapp’s “real life”. 

“Maria Von Trapp died in 1987, but the songs her life story inspired, echo still.”
---Charles Osgood, CBS News Sunday Morning, aired 1/26/2014.(1)

Of course the musical is a beautifully written sugary rendition of a fictional life with many liberties taken with the outcome of a musical in mind, rather than a historically accurate documentary recounting Maria’s life and that of her family members.

In her article,  “Movie vs. Reality: The Real Story of the von Trapp Family”, Joan Gearin writes, “Examining the historical record is helpful in separating fact from fiction, particularly in a case like the von Trapp family and The Sound of Music. In researching this article, I read Maria von Trapp's books, contemporary newspaper articles, and original documents, all of which clarified the difference between the von Trapps' real experiences and fictionalized accounts”(2)  Similarly, separating fact from fiction in our own ancestral histories and family stories takes the same research of original and historical documents.  We are given oral stories and written histories, but how many of those histories and stories are historically accurate?

The Von Trapp Family Lodge website explains:  “The Sound of Music is a musical and was never meant to be a documentary about our life. Rodgers and Hammerstein were inspired to write it after reading our mother's book, The Story of The Trapp Family. As we had given all of our rights to the German film company, we had no control over the content of The Sound of Music.”(3)  According to her family, Maria was a very powerful woman and nothing like the charming character portrayed in the musical.  Sometimes in our own written and oral histories, family members are described from a single incident, rather than a compilation of their whole life and personality.

Maria was interested and passionate about music and, “In 1944, our mother, Maria Augusta von Trapp, leased a military camp at the foot of our hill, which was about to be dismantled. She always dreamed of creating a music center to bring people together to sing. This spot was perfect!”(3)  Georg Von Trapp died in 1947 and never saw the musical.  Maria died March 28, 1987 in Morrisville, Vermont. 

The following are some facts about the Von Trapp family that are in direct conflict with the musical:

  • There were 3 children born after her marriage to Captain Von Trapp. (2)

  • The family actually took the train to Italy; they did not cross the Alps. (2)

  • Maria came to the von Trapp family in 1926 as a tutor for one of the children, Maria, who was recovering from scarlet fever, not as governess to all the children. (2)

  • Maria and Georg married in 1927, 11 years before the family left Austria, not right before the Nazi takeover of Austria. (2)

  • The names, ages, and sexes of the children were changed. (2)

  • The family was musically inclined before Maria arrived, but she did teach them to sing madrigals.(2)


There is a time and a place for a grand story and there is a time and a place for an accurate story.  Sometimes the two are so far distant that the grand story will interfere with the research for the accurate story and tracing ancestral generations.  Although The Sound of Music is a legendary musical, it will never be a historical account of the Von Trapp family. 

Sources:
(1)Charles Osgood, CBS News Sunday Morning, aired 1/26/2014.
(2)Gearin, Joan, “Movie vs. Reality: The RealStory of the von Trapp Family”, NARA, Winter 2005, Vol. 37, No. 4.  Nara:  http://www.archives.gov/publications/prologue/2005/winter/von-trapps.html
 (3) Trapp Family Lodge:  http://www.trappfamily.com/story/maria
(4)The Sound of Music http://www.the-sound-of-music-guide.com/maria-von-trapp.html

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Walking Where They Walked: Park Hotel

Image
Park Hotel, Rock Springs, Wyoming, September 2013, RR&B 19 Elk Street, Rock Springs, Sweetwater, Wyoming The Park Hotel opened in 1914 and was the hub of Western Wyoming until the late 1950’s. It was the largest and most modern hotel in the city. Advertisements boasted of hot and cold water in each of its 38 rooms, twenty of which had private baths and toilets. The fourth floor was added in the 1920’s. The Park Hotel catered to commercial men and automobile tourists traveling the Lincoln Highway. The hotel had a boisterous barroom and a sedate restaurant with sparking white table cloths. Rock Springs Miner, 30 January 1914, page 1, Wyoming Newspaper Project online. One memory of the Park Hotel, is related by Thomas P. Cullen, “One summer afternoon while walking up Elk Street toward the C Street Crossing, my attention was drawn to the small crowd assembled near the north end of the Park Hotel. A slight man, of short stature, stood rolling up his pantlegs...
Read more

What is a mortcloth?

A mortcloth, or pall, is a funeral cloth used to cover a coffin in the funeral ceremony or the deceased prior to burial.   The deceased’s family usually rented a mortcloth from the local church and after each use, the fabric was washed and readied for use again.   The word comes from the Latin word “pallium” meaning cloak. The Mortcloth case of 1792 begins:   “ For many centuries, and probably up to the 20th, the Church of Scotland was the sole supplier of mortcloths.   As the name would suggest, they were cloths used to cover the dead prior to burial, and after use, were washed ready for rehire. The Church hired these for a few pence, or in some cases loaned out these cloths, until the time of the funeral. The revenue raised by this service, typically around £40 pa, was distributed to the poor of the parish at frequent intervals.”   In the late 1780’s a local Society of Colliers decided to purchase and rent out their own mortcloths preventing the loc...
Read more

Bagillt, Flintshire, Wales

Image
Bagillt, Flintshire, Wales (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bagillt) The parish of Bagillt was gazetted on 23 May 1844, having been created from the townships of Bagillt Fawr, Bagillt Fechan, Coleshill Fawr and Coleshill Fechan, which were formerly in the parish of Holywell. It is located in the Northern part of Wales. (Genuki, http://www.genuki.org.uk/big/wal/FLN/Bagillt/index.html)   The 1841 British Census finds Margaret(2) Roberts, aged four years living with her parents and siblings in Bagillt, Flintshire, Wales. In 1831, J. Poole penned: "Bagillt is a bustling place, and will continue so, as long as her smelting and coal works go on in their present prosperous state. Well conducted boats go from this place to Chester every day; with a favorable wind, these little barks make the 17 or 18 miles in little more than two hours."   (J. Poole, Gleanings of the histories of Holywell, Flint, St. Asaph and Rhuddlan, 1831 as qtd.  in http://www.genuk...
Read more